CISSP Domain 3: Evaluation Criteria & Security Standards — Mindmap Review Study Guide
═══════════════════════════════════
PART 1: MERMAID MINDMAP
═══════════════════════════════════
mindmap
root((Evaluation Criteria))
Evaluation Criteria Overview
Independent Objective Evaluation
Certification Step
TCSEC Orange Book
TCSEC Scope and Limits
D1 Failed or Not Tested
C1 Weak Protection Mechanisms
C2 Strict Login Procedures
B1 Security Labels Required
B2 No Covert Channels
B3 Secure During Start-up
A1 Verified Design
ITSEC
ITSEC Scope and Features
Functionality vs Assurance
E0 Through E6 Levels
Common Criteria
ISO 15408 Standard
Protection Profile PP
Target of Evaluation TOE
Security Target ST
EAL1 Functionally Tested
EAL2 Structurally Tested
EAL3 Methodically Tested Checked
EAL4 Methodically Designed Reviewed
EAL5 Semi formally Designed Tested
EAL6 Semi formally Verified Tested
EAL7 Formally Verified Tested
Accreditation
Official Management Signoff
═══════════════════════════════════
PART 2: TECHNICAL DEFINITIONS & CONCEPTS
═══════════════════════════════════
Evaluation Criteria Overview
Evaluation Criteria — Independent, objective evaluation systems used to assess and compare vendor products. Vendors pay independent testing labs to evaluate products, assign ratings, and produce reports that customers can trust instead of relying on vendor marketing claims.
Certification — The comprehensive technical analysis of a solution or product by an independent testing lab to ensure it meets security needs and assign a rating. ⚠️ EXAM TIP: Certification is the technical evaluation step performed by the lab; do not confuse it with accreditation, which is management’s formal sign-off.
TCSEC (Orange Book)
TCSEC (Trusted Computer System Evaluation Criteria / Orange Book) — One of the oldest evaluation criteria systems, designed exclusively to evaluate confidentiality for single, stand-alone boxes not connected to a network.
TCSEC Functional Levels — The 7 functional levels used by TCSEC to rate products, where each level builds upon the previous:
- D1: Failed or not tested.
- C1: Weak protection mechanisms.
- C2: Strict login procedures (most common rating for products).
- B1: Security labels become a requirement.
- B2: Security labels and verification of no covert channels.
- B3: Security labels, verification of no covert channels, and must stay secure during start-up.
- A1: Verified design (highest possible rating; so secure it is virtually unusable).
⚠️ EXAM TIP: Memorize the TCSEC levels in exact order (D, C, B, A) and remember that B1 is specifically where labeling becomes a requirement.
ITSEC
ITSEC (Information Technology Security Evaluation Criteria) — A major improvement over TCSEC that can evaluate both confidentiality and integrity, and can be used for networked devices. It uses the exact same functional levels as TCSEC (D1 through A1).
Functionality vs Assurance — Functionality means what a system should do, whereas assurance means how to verify or test that it is working correctly. ITSEC evaluates both, separating them into functional levels and assurance levels.
ITSEC Evaluation Levels (E Levels) — Seven assurance levels (E0 through E6) used by ITSEC to evaluate the level of assurance a product provides. ⚠️ EXAM TIP: You do not need to memorize the specifics of the E0-E6 levels.
Common Criteria
Common Criteria (Common Criteria for Information Technology Security Evaluation) — The latest and greatest evaluation criteria, adopted as the international standard ISO 15408.
Protection Profile (PP) — A document that identifies the security requirements for a class of security devices (e.g., firewalls, smart cards).
Target of Evaluation (TOE) — The specific product or system provided by the vendor that will be evaluated (e.g., a specific Cisco ASA 5515-X Firewall).
Security Target (ST) — A document prepared by the product vendor defining the specific functional and assurance security properties and capabilities claimed to be built into the TOE.
EAL (Evaluation Assurance Level) — The 7 rating levels assigned by the independent testing lab after testing the functional and assurance aspects of the TOE.
Common Criteria EAL Ratings — The 7 EAL levels that build upon each other:
- EAL1: Functionally tested.
- EAL2: Structurally tested.
- EAL3: Methodically tested & checked.
- EAL4: Methodically designed, tested & reviewed.
- EAL5: Semi formally designed & tested.
- EAL6: Semi formally verified designed & tested.
- EAL7: Formally verified designed and tested (best possible rating).
⚠️ EXAM TIP: Highly recommend memorizing these EAL levels and their exact order, as they build upon each other.
Evaluation Criteria Comparison
| Feature | TCSEC (Orange Book) | ITSEC | Common Criteria |
|---|---|---|---|
| Status | One of the oldest | Big improvement on TCSEC | Latest and greatest |
| Evaluates | Confidentiality only | Confidentiality + Integrity | Functional & Assurance requirements |
| Network Support | Single stand-alone boxes only | Networked devices | Not explicitly stated |
| Functional Levels | D1 to A1 | Same as TCSEC (D1 to A1) | Defined by Protection Profile (PP) |
| Assurance Levels | None (combined with functional) | E0 through E6 | EAL1 through EAL7 |
| Standard | N/A | N/A | ISO 15408 |
Accreditation
Accreditation — The final step in selecting a product, consisting of official management sign-off for a set period of time to purchase and deploy the product in the organization. ⚠️ EXAM TIP: Accreditation is strictly management’s approval and sign-off for a set period of time, whereas certification is the technical analysis performed by the independent lab.