Domain 2MediumCORE

Flip Game II

We are analyzing a two-player impartial game played on a binary string consisting of '+' and '-'. - Input: A single string currentState containing characters '+' or ' '-', length between 1 and 60. - Move Rule: On your turn, you must find any occurrence of '++' in the string and flip it to '--'. You cannot make a move if no '++' exists. - Win Condition: The game ends when a player cannot make a valid move. That player loses (normal play convention). We need to determine if the starting player can guarantee a win assuming optimal play from both sides. - Output: A boolean true if Player 1 wins, false otherwise.

Domain: Medium•Updated: 2026-08-31
#Algorithms#LeetCode#qwen3.5:9b#Backtracking#Minimax

294. Flip Game II

Model: qwen3.5:9b
Topics: Backtracking,Minimax
FAANG asked: 1
Acceptance rate: 50.8%


Problem Breakdown

We are analyzing a two-player impartial game played on a binary string consisting of '+' and '-'.

  • Input: A single string currentState containing characters '+' or ' '-', length between 1 and 60.
  • Move Rule: On your turn, you must find any occurrence of "++" in the string and flip it to "--". You cannot make a move if no "++" exists.
  • Win Condition: The game ends when a player cannot make a valid move. That player loses (normal play convention). We need to determine if the starting player can guarantee a win assuming optimal play from both sides.
  • Output: A boolean true if Player 1 wins, false otherwise.

Implicit constraints: The game is finite and deterministic with perfect information. Since we are looking for a guaranteed win under optimal opponent response, this requires Minimax logic (Game Theory). Edge cases include strings where no moves exist initially or odd-length segments that prevent consecutive flips at the boundaries.

Intuition

This problem can be modeled as a decision tree rooted in Game Theory concepts like Minimax and Memoization.

  1. Brute Force: The starting player iterates through all possible valid moves (flipping every "++" found). For each move, it becomes the opponent’s turn to play on the new state.
  2. The Logic: If I can make a move that leads to a board configuration where my opponent eventually loses (i.e., returns false from their perspective), then I have won (true). Conversely, if every possible move I make allows the opponent to force me into a losing state later, I lose.
  3. Why Optimization is Needed: Without optimization, we re-evaluate identical board states multiple times as different paths lead to them (e.g., flipping index i vs index j might eventually converge on similar patterns of '+'). Given the constraint N≤60N \le 60, a raw recursive solution without caching would hit Time Limit Exceeded due to exponential branching.
  4. Key Insight: We need to memoize results for specific board states (strings). If we encounter a state we’ve already analyzed, we return its cached result immediately. This transforms the complexity from exploring every path in the tree to visiting each unique reachable game configuration once.

Approach

We will use Depth-First Search (DFS) with Memoization (@lru_cache).

  1. Define a recursive function canWin(s) that returns whether the current player can win starting from string state s.
  2. Iterate through indices ii of the string up to length - 2.
  3. Check if substring at i,i+1i, i+1 is "++". If so:
    • Construct a new state by flipping this pair to "--".
    • Recursively call canWin on the new state (this represents the opponent’s turn).
  4. Decision Logic:
    • The current player wins if there exists at least one move where the recursive call returns false (meaning the opponent loses from that resulting state). So, return True.
  5. If no moves are possible or all available moves lead to a win for the opponent (canWin(new_state) is always true), then we cannot guarantee a win; return False.

Complexity Analysis

  • Time Complexity: O(2N)O(2^N) in worst-case theoretical branching without memoization. With Memoization, it depends on the number of unique reachable states. Since each move reduces the count of '+', and valid moves are constrained by adjacency, the effective state space is significantly smaller than generic subsets. For this specific problem with N≤60N \le 60, the memoized DFS passes within time limits because many branches prune early (returning True immediately upon finding a winning move).
  • Space Complexity: O(N)O(N) for recursion stack depth and string slicing overhead, plus O(S)O(S) where SS is the number of unique states stored in the cache. Given constraints, this fits comfortably within memory limits.

Solution

from functools import lru_cache

class Solution:
    def canWin(self, currentState: str) -> bool:
        """
        Determines if the starting player can guarantee a win using Minimax with Memoization.
        
        Args:
            currentState (str): String of '+' and '-' characters
            
        Returns:
            bool: True if current player wins optimally, False otherwise
        """

        @lru_cache(None)  # Cache results for specific board states to avoid recomputation
        def dfs(s: str) -> bool:
            # Try every possible move (flip "++" at index i)
            for i in range(len(s) - 1):
                if s[i:i+2] == '++':
                    # Create new state after flipping current pair to '--'
                    next_state = s[:i] + '--' + s[i+2:]
                    
                    # If the opponent loses from this resulting state, I win.
                    # We return True immediately because we only need one winning move path.
                    if not dfs(next_state): 
                        return True
            
            # No moves available or all moves lead to a loss for current player (opponent wins)
            return False

        return dfs(currentState)

Edge Cases Handled

  • No Moves Available: If the string contains no "++" sequences, the loop completes without returning True, and the function returns False. This correctly identifies that the starting player loses immediately.
  • Short Strings (Length 1): The range for iteration (len(s) - 1) becomes empty or invalid for length < 2, preventing index errors and naturally handling single-character strings which cannot support a move.
  • All Pluses: If input is "++++", the function explores flipping middle pairs first to split the board into independent segments (e.g., "+--+"), effectively pruning branches where one side of the string becomes isolated from moves that don’t affect the win condition logic immediately.