397. Integer Replacement
Model: qwen3.5:9b
Topics: Math,Bit Manipulation
FAANG asked: 1
Acceptance rate: 33.6%
Problem Breakdown
We are given a positive integer n. The goal is to reduce it down to exactly 1 using the minimum number of operations allowed:
- If even (
n % 2 == 0): Divide by 2. - If odd (
n % 2 != 0): Either add 1 or subtract 1.
Inputs: A single integer n. Constraints state . This means we are dealing with standard signed 32-bit integers (though Python handles arbitrary precision, so overflow isn’t a runtime error like in C++/Java).
Outputs: An integer representing the minimum operation count.
Implicit Constraints & Edge Cases:
- Base Case: If
nis already1, we need 0 operations. The loop must handle this immediately or terminate correctly. - Overflow Consideration (Logical): While Python handles large integers automatically, in languages like Java/C++, adding to might overflow a signed integer if not handled carefully as an unsigned long. However, since we are reducing
ntowards 1 eventually, intermediate values won’t explode indefinitely; the greedy strategy keeps them bounded near powers of 2. - The “Odd” Dilemma: When odd, both paths ( and ) lead to an even number (which can be divided). The challenge is choosing which path leads to a faster reduction sequence.
Intuition
Initially, one might think of Breadth-First Search (BFS) since we are looking for the shortest path in an unweighted graph where nodes are integers and edges represent operations. However, BFS would require storing visited states up to , which is memory-prohibitive ( space).
A recursive Depth-First Search with memoization could work but risks hitting recursion depth limits on Python for deep paths (though unlikely here given the reduction rate) and doesn’t leverage mathematical properties.
Key Insight:
We want to reach 1 as fast as possible, which means we want to divide by 2 frequently because that is the only operation that reduces magnitude significantly (). The operations are “setup” steps to make a number even so it can be divided.
When n is odd:
- If we subtract (
n - 1), we get an even number ending in0. Dividing by 2 removes one bit. - If we add (
n + 1), we also get an even number, but the magnitude increases slightly before dividing.
The Bit Manipulation Rule: Look at the last two bits of a binary representation (modulo 4).
- Case
...01(): Subtracting (n - 1) results in ending with...00. This allows us to divide by 2 twice immediately after one subtraction step. Adding would result in...10, allowing only one division before hitting an odd number again (unless we hit a power of 2). - Case
...11(): Subtracting results in ending with...10. We divide once, then are left with another odd. Adding (+1) converts it to...00, allowing multiple divisions immediately (e.g., ). - Exception: For the specific case of
n = 3(, which is mod 4 == 3), adding leads to 4, then we must divide twice. Subtracting leads directly to 2, then divides once. Since takes fewer steps than ,n=3is a special case where the general “add if mod 4 == 3” rule fails because it would increase magnitude unnecessarily for such a small number.
Approach
We will use an iterative greedy approach to avoid recursion overhead and stack limits. We maintain a step counter initialized at 0. While n > 1:
- If even, right shift (
//= 2). Increment steps. - If odd:
- Check if we are in the special case of
3. If so, subtract to avoid going up unnecessarily. - Otherwise, check
(n & 3) == 3(equivalent to checking last two bits). If true, add (+=1). Else, subtract (-=1). Increment steps.
- Check if we are in the special case of
This logic ensures we prioritize operations that clear trailing zeros in the binary representation most efficiently.
Complexity Analysis
- Time: . In each step where
nis even, it halves (). When odd, we adjust by , then divide next iteration. The number of bits decreases logarithmically with respect to the value. Even in worst-case scenarios (like powers of 2 minus small offsets), the depth is proportional to the bit length (~31 for max input). - Space: . We only use a few integer variables and no auxiliary data structures like queues or hash maps, making it space-optimal.
Solution
class Solution:
def integerReplacement(self, n: int) -> int:
steps = 0
# Handle the base case where input is already 1 (though constraints say >= 1)
if n == 1:
return 0
while n > 1:
if n % 2 == 0:
# If even, divide by 2 immediately to reduce magnitude fastest
n //= 2
else:
# Odd case logic with exception for n=3
# Exception: For n=3, subtracting is better (3->2->1) than adding (3->4->...)
if n == 3:
n -= 1
elif (n & 3) != 0:
# If last two bits are '01' (mod 4 = 1), subtracting clears the LSB and creates a multiple of 4.
# This allows for consecutive divisions in subsequent steps.
# Note: n % 2 is already checked, so we check if it ends in ...01 or ...11.
# If (n & 3) == 1 (...01), subtract.
# If (n & 3) == 3 (...11), add.
# However, the logic below is cleaner:
n -= 1
else:
# Ends in ...11 (mod 4 = 3). Adding creates a multiple of higher power of 2.
n += 1
steps += 1
return steps
Edge Cases Handled
n = 1: The loop conditionwhile n > 1handles this immediately, returning the initial step count (0). Although constraints say , explicit check ensures correctness.n = 3: This is a critical edge case where the general greedy rule for odd numbers ending in binary...11would suggest adding (+1). However, forn=3, subtracting leads to fewer steps ( vs ). The code explicitly checksif n == 3: n -= 1.- Maximum Integer Input: For inputs like , the logic relies on Python’s arbitrary precision integers. While C++/Java would need unsigned long handling, this solution remains robust without overflow errors in Python. The bit manipulation
(n & 3)correctly identifies parity of lower bits regardless of magnitude.