Domain 2MediumCORE

Magical String

We need to generate a specific sequence $S$ based on run-length encoding rules and count occurrences of '1' within its first $N$ characters. The key constraint is that the string describes itself: if we group consecutive identical characters, their counts form the original string.

Domain: Medium•Updated: 2026-08-31
#Algorithms#LeetCode#qwen3.5:9b#FAANG asked: 1

481. Magical String

Model: qwen3.5:9b
Topics:
FAANG asked: 1
Acceptance rate: 48.1%


Problem Breakdown

We need to generate a specific sequence SS based on run-length encoding rules and count occurrences of ‘1’ within its first NN characters. The key constraint is that the string describes itself: if we group consecutive identical characters, their counts form the original string.

Inputs: An integer n (where 0≤n≤100,0000 \le n \le 100,000). Outputs: Integer count of ‘1’s in the first n elements of SS.

Constraints & Edge Cases:

  • N=0: Return 0.
  • Small N (e.g., 1 or 2): The sequence starts “1”, so for small inputs, we must ensure our generation logic doesn’t assume a pre-existing length that exceeds n before counting correctly.
  • Memory Limit: N=105N=10^5 fits easily in memory with an integer list (approx 400KB), but string concatenation would be inefficient (O(N2)O(N^2)). We must use mutable structures like lists or arrays for amortized O(1) appends.

Intuition

The sequence is self-referential, meaning we cannot derive a closed-form mathematical formula easily without simulation. A brute-force approach of generating the string character-by-character using standard string concatenation would be O(N2)O(N^2) because strings are immutable in Python (or similar languages), requiring copying data on every append operation.

The key insight is that since the sequence only contains ‘1’s and ‘2’s, we can maintain a list of integers representing counts or characters directly. We need two pointers:

  1. ptr: Tracks our position within SS to read how many times to repeat the next character (since SS itself dictates its own run lengths).
  2. next_char_type: Since contiguous groups must alternate between ‘1’ and ‘2’, we toggle this value after every group is appended.

We generate elements until our list length reaches n. This ensures we have enough data to answer the query without generating unnecessary trailing characters (though for N=105N=10^5, slight over-generation is acceptable).

Approach

  1. Initialize a list s with [1], as this is always the start of the magical string.
  2. Set our read pointer ptr = 0. This points to the next number in s that tells us how many times to append the current character type.
  3. Maintain a variable for the next character to append, starting with ‘2’ (since we just started with ‘1’).
  4. Loop while length of s is less than n:
    • Read count from s[ptr].
    • Append that many instances of next_char_type to s.
    • Increment ptr.
    • Toggle next_char_type between ‘1’ and ‘2’.
  5. Once the loop finishes, slice or iterate up to index n-1 (since lists are 0-indexed) and count occurrences of ‘1’.

Complexity Analysis

  • Time: O(N)O(N) — We visit each position in the generated string exactly once during generation. The pointer moves linearly through the list we build.
  • Space: O(N)O(N) — We store n integers (or characters) to represent the sequence up to length N.

Solution

def magicalString(n: int) -> int:
    # Edge case for n=0, though logic handles it naturally via slicing.
    if n == 0: return 0
    
    s = [1]          # Initialize with the first element '1'
    ptr = 0          # Pointer to read counts from S itself
    next_char_type = 2  # Start appending '2's since we just had a group of '1's

    while len(s) < n:
        count_needed = s[ptr]
        
        # Append the required number of characters. 
        # We append to list, not string, for O(1) amortized performance.
        if next_char_type == 2:
            s.extend([2] * count_needed)
        else:
            s.extend([1] * count_needed)
            
        ptr += 1
        
        # Toggle the character type to ensure groups alternate (RLE property)
        next_char_type = 3 - next_char_type if next_char_type in [1, 2] else None

    return sum(1 for x in s[:n] if x == 1)

Edge Cases Handled

  • N=0: Returns sum of empty slice (count is 0).
  • N=1: Loop condition fails immediately (len(s) starts at 1), returns count of [1][:1], which is 1. Correct.
  • Partial Groups: The loop generates full groups based on counts in s. If the last group exceeds length n (unlikely with this logic as we stop when len >= n, but if it did happen during generation), slicing [:n] ensures we only count valid characters within bounds.