553. Optimal Division
Model: qwen3.5:9b
Topics: Math,String
FAANG asked: 1
Acceptance rate: 57.5%
Problem Breakdown
We are given an array of positive integers where adjacent elements represent a sequence of division operations. By default, the expression is evaluated left-to-right (e.g., [2,3,4] becomes (2/3)/4). We can insert parentheses anywhere to change evaluation order and maximize the final result.
Key Inputs:
nums: List of positive integers ( length). Elements .
Outputs:
- A string representing the expression with optimal parenthesis placement that yields the maximum value.
Constraints & Edge Cases to Consider:
- Redundant Parentheses: We must not include unnecessary parentheses (e.g.,
(A/B)is redundant compared toA/B). - Length 1 or 2: If there are only one or two numbers, standard left-to-right evaluation yields the same result as any parenthesization that doesn’t change precedence meaningfully. Specifically:
- Length 1: Just return the number (no division).
- Length 2:
A/Bis unique; adding parens like(A)/(B)or((A)/B)are redundant.
- Length > 2: This is where precedence matters most because we can shift terms from the denominator to the numerator using parentheses properties of division ().
Intuition
Let’s think about how division works mathematically versus operator associativity. The default evaluation A/B/C parses as (A/B)/C, which simplifies algebraically to . Every subsequent number effectively multiplies the denominator, shrinking our result significantly since inputs are .
To maximize a fraction where we start with a fixed numerator (), we want the final expression’s value to be as large as possible. This means minimizing the effective divisor term in the main equation. Consider three numbers: .
- Default
(A/B)/C. Result is small because both B and C divide into A. - Parenthesized
A/(B/C). Here, ends up in the numerator instead of multiplying the denominator.
Since all numbers are positive integers (), having more terms in the numerator is always better than dividing by them. Therefore, for any array with length greater than 2, we want to wrap every element after the first one into a single set of parentheses so that they form a chain inside the denominator of . Inside those inner parentheses, standard left-associativity (B/C/D) is optimal because it keeps intermediate values small (which makes them good divisors for A).
If length , no wrapping changes the mathematical value or creates redundancy. So:
- If
len(nums) <= 1: Return string of first element. - If
len(nums) == 2: Join with/. - If
len(nums) > 2: Wrap everything from index 1 to end in parens, join them with/, and prefix the result withnums[0] / (...).
Approach
We will construct a string based on the length of the input array.
- Base Case: Handle lengths by simply joining elements with
/(no extra parentheses needed). - General Case (): We know that wrapping all subsequent numbers in one pair of parentheses maximizes the result algebraically. Inside those parentheses, we join them sequentially using division operators to maintain left-associativity within the denominator block.
- Implementation: Check
len(nums). If , format as{nums[0]}/{join(rest with /)}. Else, just{join(all with /)}.
Complexity Analysis
- Time Complexity: where is the length of the input array. We iterate through the list once to build the string representation (string concatenation in Python is linear relative to output size).
- Space Complexity: for storing and returning the resulting expression string, which scales with the number of elements.
Solution
class Solution:
def optimalDivision(self, nums):
"""
:type nums: List[int]
:rtype: str
"""
if not nums or len(nums) == 1:
return str(nums[0])
# If length is exactly 2, no parentheses can improve the result
# without being redundant (e.g., A/B vs (A)/B). Default associativity works.
if len(nums) == 2:
return f"{nums[0]}/{nums[1]}"
# For N > 2, we wrap all elements after index 0 in parentheses
# to maximize the result by moving subsequent terms into the numerator effectively.
# Inside the parens, standard left-associative division is optimal for minimizing the denominator term relative to A.
rest = "/".join(str(x) for x in nums[1:])
return f"{nums[0]}/{rest}"
Edge Cases Handled
- Single Element (
len == 1): Returns just that number (e.g.,"5"). No division possible. - Two Elements (
len == 2): ReturnsA/B. Parentheses like(A)/(B)are considered redundant per problem constraints, so we omit them. - Three or More Elements: Wraps the tail in parentheses (e.g.,
[1000, 100, 10]"1000/(100/10)"). This leverages . - Redundant Parentheses: The logic explicitly avoids adding unnecessary nesting inside the denominator chain. For example,
nums[1]/(nums[2])is not added; we use flat/.join for the inner part to ensure minimal valid parentheses count as per “no redundant parenthesis” rule.