574. Winning Candidate
Model: qwen3.5:9b
Topics:
FAANG asked: 0
Acceptance rate: 52.7%
Problem Breakdown
We are given a database scenario involving two tables: Candidates (containing candidate IDs and names) and Votes (recording which candidates received votes). The goal is to identify the “winning” candidate(s)—those with the highest total vote count.
Inputs:
- Two relational structures (
Candidate,Vote). - Implicitly, we assume valid integer keys for joining.
Outputs:
- A list of winning candidates (ID and Name) who have received the maximum number of votes compared to all others.
Constraints & Edge Cases:
- Ties: If multiple candidates share the highest vote count, should we return one or all? In a robust system design context, returning all winners is safer unless specified otherwise (e.g., “lowest ID wins”). I will handle ties by including all max-vote holders to avoid data loss.
- Empty Data: If no votes exist for any candidate, the result should be an empty set or nulls handled gracefully.
- Null Values: Ensure we don’t count
NULLvote entries as valid votes (standard SQL behavior).
Intuition
A brute-force approach would iterate through every row in the Votes table to manually tally counts for each candidate, then compare them pairwise to find the maximum. This is inefficient () and unnecessary given relational capabilities.
The key insight is aggregation. We don’t need to know individual votes; we only care about totals per candidate. By grouping by candidateId first, we reduce rows (votes) into groups (candidates). Once aggregated, finding the maximum count becomes a simple sort or window function operation ().
In an interview setting, I would explain that while SQL is declarative for this task, implementing it in Python demonstrates understanding of data manipulation logic: Join -> Group By Count -> Filter Max.
Approach
- Join: Merge the
CandidatesandVotestables on the candidate ID to ensure we only count votes for valid candidates (prevents counting orphaned vote records). - Aggregate: Use a group-by operation (
groupby) with.size()or.count()to calculate total votes per candidate. This transforms rows into counts. - Identify Max: Determine the maximum vote count across all groups.
- Filter & Sort: Filter for candidates matching that max count and sort by ID (optional, but good practice) before returning results.
This mirrors a SQL query using JOIN, GROUP BY HAVING COUNT(*) = MAX(...). In Python/Pandas, this maps directly to .merge(), .groupby().size(), and filtering logic.
Complexity Analysis
- Time: where is the number of votes (for sorting/grouping) and is the number of candidates (). The dominant cost is typically the sort or hash aggregation during grouping.
- Space: , where is memory for intermediate join results and stores unique candidate counts in our groupby object.
Solution
import pandas as pd
def get_winning_candidate(candidates: list[dict], votes: list[dict]) -> list[tuple]:
"""
Identifies the winning candidate(s) based on vote count.
Args:
candidates: List of dicts representing 'Candidates' table (id, name).
votes: List of dicts representing 'Votes' table (candidateId).
Returns:
List of tuples containing (id, name) for all winners with max votes.
"""
# Convert lists to DataFrames for efficient tabular operations
df_candidates = pd.DataFrame(candidates) if candidates else None
df_votes = pd.DataFrame(votes) if votes else None
# Handle empty input cases gracefully
if not df_candidates or not df_votes:
return []
# Join tables on candidate ID to ensure we only count valid votes for known candidates
merged_df = pd.merge(df_candidates, df_votes[['candidateId']],
left_on='id', right_on='candidateId', how='left')
# Drop rows where join failed (candidates with no votes) if necessary.
# However, usually we want to count 0 for candidates without votes?
# For "Winning Candidate", typically only those who received votes matter or
# the schema implies every candidate has at least one vote record in 'Votes'.
# We will drop rows where no match was found (candidates with 0 votes)
# unless they are relevant to tie-breaking. Standard SQL problem usually ignores non-voted candidates for "winner".
merged_df = merged_df.dropna(subset=['candidateId'])
if len(merged_df) == 0:
return []
# Aggregate vote counts per candidate ID
agg_counts = merged_df.groupby('id').size().reset_index(name='vote_count')
# Find the maximum vote count achieved in this election cycle
max_votes = agg_counts['vote_count'].max()
# Filter for candidates who received exactly that many votes (handles ties)
winners = agg_counts[agg_counts['vote_count'] == max_votes]
return list(zip(winners['id'], winners['name']))
Edge Cases Handled
- No Votes: If
votesis empty, the function returns an empty list immediately. - Ties in Vote Count: The logic filters for all candidates matching the maximum vote count (
vote_count == max_votes) rather than arbitrarily picking one (e.g., via LIMIT 1), ensuring fairness if multiple winners exist. - Missing Candidates: Rows where a candidate ID exists but has no votes are dropped during
dropnabefore aggregation, preventing them from skewing the “winner” status unless they have actual vote records.