Domain 2MediumMEDIUM

Soup Servings

LeetCode problem 808: Soup Servings (medium).

Domain: medium•Updated: 2026-09-01
#Dynamic Programming

Problem Breakdown

We are given an initial volume N for two soups, A and B. We perform operations that reduce these volumes by specific amounts (multiples of 25). Each operation has a probability of 0.25. The process stops when either soup runs out (≤0\le 0 ml remaining).

Goal: Calculate the expected value: P(A empty first)+0.5×P(A and B empty simultaneously)P(A \text{ empty first}) + 0.5 \times P(\text{A and B empty simultaneously})

Inputs & Constraints:

  • N: Integer, 0≤N≤1090 \le N \le 10^9.
  • Output: Float representing the probability metric.
  • Implicit Constraint: The state space is large (O(N)O(N)), but we cannot iterate up to 10910^9 due to time limits (TLE). We must rely on mathematical convergence properties or early termination based on floating-point precision tolerance.

Edge Cases:

  • N = 0: Both soups are empty immediately. This counts as simultaneous emptiness, returning 0.5. However, standard DP logic often handles this via base cases where both ≤0\le 0.
  • Large N (>≈4800> \approx 4800): The probability converges to 1 so closely that for the required precision (1e-6), we can return 1 directly without computation.

Intuition

A naive Dynamic Programming (DP) approach would define a state as (a, b) representing remaining volumes of A and B. Since each operation subtracts at least 25 ml from one soup, the depth is roughly N/25N/25. The number of states could be up to (4×N/100)2(4 \times N / 100)^2 or similar depending on implementation, which for N = 10^9 results in an unmanageable state space (O(N2)O(N^2)).

Key Insight: The operations subtract more volume from A than B on average. Specifically:

  • Expected reduction per turn for A: (100+75+50+25)/4=62.5(100 + 75 + 50 + 25) / 4 = 62.5 ml.
  • Expected reduction per turn for B: (0+25+50+75)/4=37.5(0 + 25 + 50 + 75) / 4 = 37.5 ml.

Since A depletes faster on average, the probability that A empties first approaches 1 as N increases. Due to floating-point precision limits (double precision has ~15-17 decimal digits), once N is large enough, the calculated probability will be indistinguishable from 1 within the allowed error margin (10−610^{-6}). We can empirically determine a threshold (around 4800) where we stop calculating and return 1.

Approach

  1. Threshold Check: If N exceeds ~4800, immediately return 1. This handles large inputs in O(1)O(1) time.
  2. Memoization Setup: For smaller N, use a recursive function with memoization (or an iterative DP table) to avoid recomputing states (a, b).
  3. Recursive Relation: Define dp(a, b) as the probability for remaining volumes a and b:
    • If a <= 0 and b > 0: A emptied first →\rightarrow return 1.
    • If a > 0 and b <= 0: B emptied first (A didn’t) →\rightarrow return 0.
    • If both <= 0: Simultaneous emptying →\rightarrow return 0.5.
    • Otherwise: Average the four recursive calls with weight 0.25 each, clamping negative volumes to 0 for indexing purposes (or handling logic inside). Note that we clamp inputs in recursion arguments or check base cases first. Actually, standard practice is max(0, a - amount) but since we return immediately on ≤0\le 0, passing the raw result works if handled correctly.
  4. Execution: Call the recursive function with initial (N, N).

Complexity Analysis

  • Time Complexity: O(N2)O(N^2) in worst case without threshold optimization (DP table size). However, due to the early termination at threshold, it effectively becomes O(1)O(1) for large inputs and roughly constant time relative to small inputs because we only compute up to ≈4800\approx 4800. The number of states visited is bounded by (Threshold/25)2×(… )(\text{Threshold}/25)^2 \times (\dots).
  • Space Complexity: O(N2)O(N^2) (or rather, proportional to the threshold squared for memoization cache). With N capped at ~4800 and step sizes being multiples of 25, this fits easily in memory.

Solution

from functools import lru_cache

class SoupServings:
    def soupServings(self, N: int) -> float:
        # Optimization threshold based on floating point precision convergence.
        # For N > ~4800, the probability is effectively 1 within tolerance (1e-6).
        if N >= 5000: 
            return 1.0
        
        @lru_cache(None)
        def dp(a: int, b: int) -> float:
            # Base cases for when soup runs out
            if a <= 0 and b > 0:
                return 1.0       # A emptied first
            elif a > 0 and b <= 0:
                return 0.0       # B emptied first (A didn't)
            elif a <= 0 and b <= 0:
                return 0.5       # Both empty at same time
            
            # Recursive step with equal probability for each operation
            prob = 0.25 * sum([
                dp(max(0, a - 100), max(0, b)),      # Op 1
                dp(max(0, a - 75), max(0, b - 25)),  # Op 2
                dp(max(0, a - 50), max(0, b - 50)),  # Op 3
                dp(max(0, a - 25), max(0, b - 75))   # Op 4
            ])
            
            return prob
        
        return dp(N, N)

# Example usage:
# print(SoupServings().soupServings(50)) 

Edge Cases Handled

  • Large N (10910^9): The threshold check (if N >= 5000) prevents Time Limit Exceeded (TLE) and Memory Limit Exceeded (MLE). It returns the converged value of 1.0 immediately, satisfying precision requirements without computation.
  • Small N / Base Cases: The recursive function handles states where soup volumes drop to ≤0\le 0. Specifically:
    • If only A is empty (a <= 0, b > 0), it returns 1 (A empties first).
    • If both are empty, it returns 0.5 (simultaneous).
  • Floating Point Precision: The threshold logic ensures we don’t attempt to calculate probabilities that differ from 1 by less than machine epsilon relative to the required tolerance (10−610^{-6}), avoiding unnecessary precision loss or infinite loops in theoretical scenarios.