Problem Breakdown
We are given an array representing the number of customers entering per minute and a binary array indicating if the owner is grumpy at that specific minute (1 for grumpy, 0 otherwise). The goal is to maximize total satisfied customers by using a secret technique exactly once. This technique allows us to suppress “grumpiness” (make it effectively 0) for a contiguous duration of X minutes.
Inputs:
customers: List of integers representing customer count per minute.grumpy: Binary list indicating grumpiness status (1or0).X: Integer length of the window where we can apply the technique (make owner not grumpy).
Output:
- An integer: The maximum number of satisfied customers possible.
Constraints & Edge Cases to Consider:
- Lengths: Arrays are up to 20,000 elements;
Xis between 1 and array length. This suggests an or solution is required (avoiding quadratic time). - Values: Customer counts can be zero. Grumpiness is strictly binary. No negative values exist per constraints, but logic should handle
0gracefully. - Overflow: Python handles large integers automatically, so standard sum accumulation won’t overflow 32-bit limits even if the total exceeds . However, in languages like Java/C++, we would need to ensure sums fit within integer types (though max possible here is , which fits easily).
- Window Coverage: If
Xequals the array length, the technique covers everything. The logic should naturally handle this without special casing if implemented correctly via sliding window.
Intuition
Let’s start with a naive approach to understand what we are optimizing for. A brute force solution would iterate through every possible starting position of the X-minute window (there are such windows). For each window, we calculate:
- The customers satisfied naturally outside this window (
grumpy[i] == 0). - Plus all customers inside the chosen window (since they become satisfied due to the technique).
Why Brute Force is Insufficient:
Calculating the sum for every possible window naively takes per position, leading to an overall time complexity of . Given constraints where both can be up to 20,000, this could approach operations in worst-case scenarios (e.g., X is large), which risks Time Limit Exceeded.
Key Insight: We can decompose the total satisfied customers into two independent parts:
- Base Satisfaction: Customers who are already satisfied because the owner isn’t grumpy (
grumpy[i] == 0). This count never changes regardless of where we apply our technique, as those minutes remain non-grumpy naturally or stay within a window (where they don’t add extra value). We can calculate this sum once. - Potential Gain: The additional customers satisfied by applying the technique on grumpy minutes (
grumpy[i] == 1).
The problem transforms into: Find the contiguous subarray of length X that contains the maximum number of “lost” (unsatisfied) customers due to grumpiness, and add this sum to our Base Satisfaction. This is a classic Sliding Window pattern where we only care about values inside the window when they contribute to gain.
Approach
- Calculate Base Satisfaction: Iterate through
customersonce. Sum up allcustomers[i]wheregrumpy[i] == 0. - Initialize Sliding Window for Gain: Create a variable (e.g.,
current_gain) initialized to the sum of customers in the first window[0, X-1]only if they are grumpy (grumpy[i] == 1). - Slide the Window: Iterate from index
i = Xup toN - 1.- Add the new element entering the window (at
i) to gain only if it is a grumpy minute. - Remove the old element leaving the window (at
i - X) from gain only if it was a grumpy minute.
- Add the new element entering the window (at
- Track Maximum: Keep updating a variable (
max_gain) with the maximum value ofcurrent_gainseen during the slide. - Final Result: Return
base_satisfaction + max_gain.
Complexity Analysis
- Time Complexity:
- We iterate through the array to calculate base satisfaction ().
- We perform a single pass with the sliding window, performing constant time operations per element ( amortized) for each step. Total is linear relative to input size
N.
- Space Complexity:
- We use only a few integer variables (
base_satisfied,current_gain,max_gain) regardless of the input size. No auxiliary data structures like hash maps or extra arrays are required beyond the inputs themselves.
- We use only a few integer variables (
Solution
def maxSatisfied(customers, grumpy, X):
n = len(customers)
# 1. Calculate base satisfaction (customers satisfied naturally where owner is not grumpy)
base_satisfaction = sum(c for c, g in zip(customers, grumpy) if g == 0)
# 2. Initialize sliding window gain calculation
# We only care about customers when the owner IS grumpy inside our technique window
current_gain = sum(c for i, (c, g) in enumerate(zip(customers, grumpy))
if X > i and g == 1)
max_gain = current_gain
# 3. Slide the window across the array
# We start sliding from index X to n-1
for i in range(X, n):
entering_customer_idx = i
leaving_customer_idx = i - X
c_entering = customers[entering_customer_idx]
g_entering = grumpy[entering_customer_idx]
c_leaving = customers[leaving_customer_idx]
g_leaving = grumpy[leaving_customer_idx]
# Update gain: add entering if they were originally unsatisfied (grumpy),
# remove leaving only if they contributed to the previous window's loss.
if g_entering == 1:
current_gain += c_entering
if g_leaving == 1:
current_gain -= c_leaving
max_gain = max(max_gain, current_gain)
return base_satisfaction + max_gain
# Example usage matching the problem description
if __name__ == "__main__":
customers = [1,0,1,2,1,1,7,5]
grumpy = [0,1,0,1,0,1,0,1]
X = 3
print(maxSatisfied(customers, grumpy, X)) # Output: 16
Edge Cases Handled
- X equals array length: The loop range for sliding will effectively not execute or handle the single window correctly.
current_gainis calculated initially covering all elements wheregrumpy[i] == 1. If this covers everything, it returns base (0) + total grumpy customers = correct result. - No Grumpy Minutes: The initial sum for gain will be 0. Since no minutes are unsatisfied naturally (
base_satisfactioncaptures all), the loop updatescurrent_gainto remain 0. Result is simply total customers, which is correct. - All Customers Unsatisfied (Grumpy): If every minute has
grumpy[i] == 1, thenbase_satisfactionstarts at 0. The sliding window will find the maximum sum of any contiguous subarray of length X within the customer array. This correctly identifies the best minutes to save using the technique. - X = 1: The logic holds; it simply checks every single minute individually for gain and adds max found to base satisfaction.