Problem Breakdown
We need to identify a specific pattern of three website visits (a “3-sequence”) that is most popular across different users.
Inputs:
username: List of strings identifying who visited.timestamp: List of integers indicating when each visit occurred.website: List of strings for the URL/path visited at that time.
All three lists are aligned by index , meaning (username[i], timestamp[i], website[i]) is a single event.
Output:
A list containing exactly 3 websites [w1, w2, w3]. This sequence must be valid (chronologically ordered) and visited by the maximum number of distinct users. If multiple sequences share that max count, return the one that comes first alphabetically (lexicographically smallest).
Implicit Constraints & Edge Cases:
- User Isolation: A 3-sequence is only counted if all three visits belong to the same user. Visits from different users at similar times do not combine into a single sequence for counting purposes.
- Chronology: For any triplet of websites chosen by a user, they must be ordered strictly by timestamp (). Since timestamps are unique per visit (no two visits at same time), sorting the user’s history resolves this order automatically.
- Small N: The total number of events . This suggests we can afford combinatorial logic () without needing complex optimizations, but clarity is key for a senior engineer interview.
- Guarantees: We are guaranteed at least one user visits 3 websites, so the result will never be undefined or empty regarding valid sequences.
Intuition
- Grouping by User: The core constraint is that a sequence must belong to a single user. If we treat all events as a flat stream, we lose ownership information. We need to partition the data into buckets per
username. - Ordering Visits: Within each bucket (user), visits might not be in chronological order relative to other users’ timestamps or even their own previous entries if input isn’t sorted globally by time for that user. However, since we only care about relative ordering within a user’s history, sorting the events of a specific user by
timestampis essential before extracting sequences. - Generating Sequences: Once a user has visits in chronological order (sorted list), any combination of 3 distinct indices where forms a valid “3-sequence” because the timestamps are strictly increasing by definition.
- Counting and Selecting: We aggregate these sequences into a frequency map (e.g.,
Counter). Finally, we scan this map to find the maximum count. Python’s tuple comparison handles lexicographical ordering naturally when iterating or sorting keys with equal values.
Why Brute Force is Insufficient?
A naive approach might try every triplet from the raw input arrays () and check if they belong to one user by checking username equality for all three indices. While technically , this misses the structural insight that we must group first. More importantly, without grouping, you cannot efficiently determine which users contributed to a specific sequence string combination because timestamps are not unique globally (though they might be in examples). Grouping ensures correctness and makes complexity analysis cleaner ( vs where is visits per user).
Approach
- Data Structure Setup: Initialize a dictionary mapping
usernameto a list of(timestamp, website)tuples. - Grouping & Sorting: Iterate through the input arrays simultaneously (using
zip). Populate the dictionary lists. For each user’s visit history, sort by timestamp ascendingly. This ensures that for any combination we pick later, the time order is respected implicitly. - Sequence Extraction: Initialize a global counter (
collections.Counter) to track frequency of website triplets. Iterate through everyusernamein our dictionary:- Extract just the websites from their sorted history into a list (since timestamps are now ordered).
- Generate all combinations of size 3 using indices .
- Increment the counter for each resulting tuple
(w[i], w[j], w[k]).
- Finding Result: Iterate through the items in our global counter. Track the maximum count seen so far (
max_count). If a sequence hascount > max_count, update result and reset tracking logic (or handle tie-breaking).- Optimization: Since we need lexicographically smallest on ties, it is often easier to sort all unique sequences found by frequency descending, then primary key ascending. Or simply iterate the counter items; if current count equals
max_countbut sequence < result_sequence, update.
- Optimization: Since we need lexicographically smallest on ties, it is often easier to sort all unique sequences found by frequency descending, then primary key ascending. Or simply iterate the counter items; if current count equals
- Return: Return the list of strings for the winning sequence.
Complexity Analysis
- Time Complexity: where is total visits and is number of unique valid sequences found (bounded by ).
- Grouping takes .
- Sorting per user: In worst case one user has all , so . If distributed, sum of sorts is bounded similarly.
- Generating combinations: For a single user with visits, we generate sequences. Summing over users, the total number of generated tuples across all inputs cannot exceed . With , this is roughly 20,000 operations, which is negligible.
- Counter updates and final scan are linear with respect to unique sequences found ().
- Space Complexity: where is the number of distinct website triplets encountered (stored in the counter) plus space for storing user visit lists. In worst case, this could be proportional to .
Solution
from collections import defaultdict, Counter
import itertools
def mostVisitedPattern(username: list[str], timestamp: list[int], website: list[str]) -> list[str]:
# 1. Group visits by username and store as (timestamp, website) tuples
user_visits = defaultdict(list)
for u_name, t_time, w_site in zip(username, timestamp, website):
user_visits[u_name].append((t_time, w_site))
# 2. Frequency map to count how many users visited each specific sequence
pattern_counts = Counter()
# 3. Process each user's history
for visits in user_visits.values():
if len(visits) < 3:
continue
# Sort by timestamp to ensure chronological order of websites
visits.sort(key=lambda x: x[0])
# Extract just the website names since they are now sorted chronologically
sites = [w for _, w in visits]
# Generate all combinations of 3 distinct indices (i < j < k)
# Since we sorted by time, any combination forms a valid chronological sequence
for triplet in itertools.combinations(sites, 3):
pattern_counts[triplet] += 1
# 4. Find the max count and handle lexicographical tie-breaking
if not pattern_counts:
return []
best_sequence = None
max_count = -1
for sequence, count in pattern_counts.items():
if count > max_count:
max_count = count
best_sequence = sequence
elif count == max_count and (best_sequence is None or sequence < best_sequence):
# Tie-breaker: lexicographically smallest
best_sequence = sequence
return list(best_sequence)
# Example usage matching the problem description logic implicitly handled above.
Edge Cases Handled
- Users with fewer than 3 visits: The code checks
if len(visits) < 3and skips them, as they cannot form a valid triplet. This is safe because we only care about sequences formed by users who visited at least 3 times (guaranteed to exist). - Unsorted Input Timestamps per User: We explicitly sort each user’s visit list
visits.sort(key=lambda x: x[0])before generating combinations, ensuring the website order reflects time. - Lexicographical Ties: The logic inside the loop checks if a new sequence has an equal count to the current best but is lexicographically smaller (
sequence < best_sequence). This ensures we return the correct tie-breaker result. - Empty Result (Theoretical): While constraints guarantee at least one valid user, the code handles
if not pattern_countsjust in case inputs were malformed or violated guarantees gracefully by returning an empty list.