Problem Breakdown
We are given two arrays of strings: queries (the questions) and words (the reference set). For each string, we define a function which counts the frequency of its lexicographically smallest character.
- Goal: For every query in
queries, count how many words inwordshave an value strictly greater than that specific query’s value (). - Inputs: Two lists of strings (
queries,words). Constraints indicate lengths are small (up to 10) and arrays up to 2000 elements, with lowercase English letters only. - Outputs: A list of integers representing the count for each query.
Intuition
- Brute Force: For each query , iterate through every word . Calculate and . If , increment a counter for that query.
- Complexity: Let be number of queries, words, string length. Time is roughly . With given constraints (), this might pass but risks TLE in Python due to interpreter overhead on nested loops, and it doesn’t scale if inputs grow.
- Optimization: Notice that is constant regardless of the query. We can compute all word scores upfront ().
- Querying Strategy: If we store these precomputed word scores in a sorted list, for any new query score, we only need to find how many stored values are greater than it. This transforms the per-query cost from to .
- Further Optimization (Senior Insight): Since string length is capped at 10, the maximum possible frequency is also small (). We could use a bucket array (frequency map of frequencies) and prefix sums for lookup per query after preprocessing. However, sorting + binary search (
bisect) is more generic and idiomatic in Python interviews unless strict constant-time queries are required with massive data ranges. I will implement the Sorting approach as it balances readability and performance well within constraints while demonstrating algorithmic thinking about separating computation from comparison.
Approach
- Define Helper: Create a function to compute . We find the smallest character in
s(using built-inmin) and count its occurrences using.count(). Since strings are short, this is efficient enough (). - Precompute Word Scores: Iterate through every word in
words, calculate their respective scores using the helper function, and store them in a list calledword_scores. - Sort: Sort
word_scoresin ascending order. This enables binary search operations to quickly determine how many words have a score greater than or equal to (or strictly greater than) our query’s threshold. - Process Queries: For each query string:
- Calculate its value (
query_score). - Use
bisect_rightfrom the standard library onword_scores. This returns an insertion point where all elements to the left arequery_score. - The number of words strictly greater than
query_scoreis simply the total length minus this index.
- Calculate its value (
- Return: Collect these counts into a result list and return it.
Complexity Analysis
- Time Complexity:
- Calculating scores for all words: .
- Sorting word scores: .
- Processing queries: For each of the queries, we calculate score () and binary search (). Total query time is .
- Overall: . Given constraints, this is highly efficient.
- Space Complexity:
- We store the scores for all words in a list of size . Sorting modifies it in place or uses stack space proportional to recursion depth (iterative sort). The bucket approach would use constant extra space relative to alphabet/length limits. Here, we need storage for word frequencies: .
Solution
import bisect
from typing import List
class Solution:
def compareStrings(self, queries: List[str], words: List[str]) -> List[int]:
# Helper function to calculate f(s)
def get_f(s):
if not s:
return 0
# Find the lexicographically smallest character efficiently
min_char = min(s)
# Count occurrences of that specific character
count = s.count(min_char)
return count
# Precompute scores for all words and sort them to enable binary search
word_scores = []
for w in words:
word_scores.append(get_f(w))
word_scores.sort()
answer = []
# Process each query using binary search on the sorted list of word scores
for q in queries:
f_q = get_f(q)
# bisect_right returns an insertion point i such that all e in a[:i] <= x
# and all e in a[i:] > x.
# We want count where f(word) > f(query), which corresponds to elements after index i.
idx = bisect.bisect_right(word_scores, f_q)
answer.append(len(word_scores) - idx)
return answer
# Note: Ensure List is imported from typing if running locally without type hints context