1280. Students and Examinations
Model: qwen2.5-coder:14b
Topics:
FAANG asked: 0
Acceptance rate: 75.3%
Problem Breakdown
The problem involves two tables: Students and Examinations. The Students table contains student IDs and their names, while the Examinations table records which students took which exams. We need to find out how many times each student has taken each exam.
Inputs:
Students: A table with columnsstudent_id(integer) andstudent_name(string).Examinations: A table with columnsstudent_id(integer) andexam_id(integer).
Outputs:
- A result set that includes the student name, exam ID, and the count of how many times each student has taken each exam. The result should be ordered by
student_namein ascending order.
Implicit Constraints or Tricky Edge Cases:
- Duplicates in the
Examinationstable (a student taking an exam multiple times). - Students who have not taken any exams.
- Exams that no students have taken.
Intuition
The brute-force approach would involve iterating over each student and counting their occurrences for each exam. This would be inefficient, especially if the number of students or exams is large, as it would require nested loops.
A better approach involves using SQL’s GROUP BY clause to aggregate the data efficiently. By grouping by both student_id and exam_id, we can count the occurrences directly in the database, which is much faster than processing the data in application code.
Approach
- Join Tables: First, join the
Studentstable with theExaminationstable onstudent_idto get a combined dataset that includes student names and their exam IDs. - Group By: Group the result by both
student_nameandexam_id. - Count Occurrences: Use the
COUNT(*)function to count how many times each student has taken each exam. - Order Results: Order the final result set by
student_namein ascending order.
Complexity Analysis
- Time Complexity: The time complexity is O(n log n) due to the sorting operation, where n is the number of unique (student, exam) pairs.
- Space Complexity: The space complexity is O(n) for storing the intermediate and final result sets.
Solution
import pandas as pd
def students_and_examinations(students: pd.DataFrame, examinations: pd.DataFrame) -> pd.DataFrame:
# Join the Students and Examinations tables on student_id
joined_df = students.merge(examinations, on='student_id', how='left')
# Group by student_name and exam_id, then count occurrences
grouped_df = joined_df.groupby(['student_name', 'exam_id']).size().reset_index(name='count')
# Sort the result by student_name in ascending order
sorted_df = grouped_df.sort_values(by=['student_name'], ascending=True)
return sorted_df[['student_name', 'exam_id', 'count']]
Edge Cases Handled
- Students with no exams: The
LEFT JOINensures that students who have not taken any exams are included in the result set with a count of 0. - Exams with no students: These will naturally be excluded from the result set since they do not appear in the joined table.
- Duplicates in Examinations: The
GROUP BYclause andCOUNT(*)function handle duplicates by counting them as separate occurrences.