Problem Breakdown
We are given an interval [lo, hi] and asked to find the k-th integer in that range when sorted by a specific metric called “Power”. The Power of a number is defined via the Collatz conjecture sequence (steps until 1). If two numbers have equal power, we break ties using their natural ascending order.
Inputs:
lo: Lower bound of interval (inclusive)hi: Upper bound of interval (inclusive)k: The rank to retrieve after sorting (1-indexed in problem description, 0-indexed for implementation).
Outputs:
- An integer from the range
[lo, hi].
Implicit Constraints & Edge Cases:
- Range Size: Max difference is . This suggests an solution where is the count of numbers in range.
- Collatz Behavior: The problem guarantees termination within a reasonable number of steps (fits in integer). We don’t need to handle infinite loops or overflow for standard inputs here, but we must ensure our power calculation doesn’t exceed time limits if constraints were larger.
- Ties: Python’s
sortis stable and tuples compare element-wise naturally ((power1, val)vs(power2, val)) which handles the tie-breaking requirement automatically without extra logic.
Intuition
The core task involves two distinct phases: calculation and ordering.
-
Calculation Phase: For every number in
[lo, hi], we need to determine its “Power”. This is a recursive process ( or ). Since many numbers share sub-sequences (e.g., if you reach an even number, the next step is deterministic), this looks like traversing a functional graph.- Brute Force: Compute power for each number independently from scratch every time. Complexity: where is average steps to 1. Given constraints (), this is trivial but inefficient if we were solving a larger version of the problem (e.g., up to ).
- Optimization: Use memoization (
cache) to store computed powers. If during calculation forxwe encounter a number already in our cache, reuse that result.
-
Ordering Phase: Once we have
(power, value)pairs for all numbers, sorting them is straightforward. We want ascending power first, then ascending value. Python’s default tuple sort behavior matches this exactly: it sorts by the first element (power), and if equal, compares the second (value). -
Retrieval: After sorting, we simply access index
k-1.
Approach
- Initialize a dictionary (or hash map) to store computed power values for memoization optimization.
- Define a helper function
get_power(n)that:- Checks if
nis in the cache; return cached value if present. - If even, recurse on
n // 2. - If odd, recurse on
(3 * n) + 1. - Base case: returns 0 for input
1(since it takes 0 steps to reach itself). Note: The problem counts the step count. Usually defined as number of operations. Let’s trace Example 1 carefully: Power(3)=7. Sequence: 3->10->5->16->8->4->2->1. That is 7 transitions. Soget_power(1)should return 0 steps to reach itself? Wait, the definition says “steps needed to transform x into 1”. If , steps = 0.
- Checks if
- Iterate from
lotohi. For each number:- Calculate its power using the helper function (with memoization).
- Store as a tuple
(power, num)in a list.
- Sort the list of tuples. Python sorts lexicographically by default, which satisfies “ascending power” then “ascending value”.
- Return
sorted_list[k-1][1](the original number at index k).
Complexity Analysis
- Time Complexity: where and is the total cost of computing powers. Computing power for a single integer takes roughly proportional to its Collatz sequence length (bounded by ~500 steps). With memoization, overlapping subproblems are solved once across all queries in
[lo, hi]. Sorting dominates with . - Space Complexity: to store the list of tuples and the cache dictionary.
Solution
class Solution:
def getKth(self, lo: int, hi: int, k: int) -> int:
# Cache for memoization to avoid recalculating power values
# if we encounter numbers in a sequence that have been computed before.
cache = {}
def calculate_power(n):
"""Calculates the Collatz steps (Power) with memoization."""
if n == 1:
return 0
if n not in cache:
# Recursive step based on problem definition
next_val = n // 2 if n % 2 == 0 else 3 * n + 1
steps = calculate_power(next_val)
# Store result before returning to build the cache for future lookups
cache[n] = steps + 1
return cache[n]
# Generate list of (power, number) tuples for all integers in range [lo, hi]
sorted_nums = []
for num in range(lo, hi + 1):
power_val = calculate_power(num)
sorted_nums.append((power_val, num))
# Sort by power ascending. Python's default tuple sort handles
# the secondary condition (ascending value automatically).
sorted_nums.sort()
# Return the k-th element (convert 1-based k to 0-based index)
return sorted_nums[k - 1][1]
Edge Cases Handled
- Single Element Range (
lo == hi): The loop runs once, list has one item,k=1, returns that number. Correctly handled by range logic and indexing. - Tie-Breaking: If multiple numbers have the same power (e.g., 12 and 13 in Example 1), Python’s tuple sort compares
(power, val). Since powers are equal, it comparesval, ensuring smaller number comes first as required. - Memoization Overhead: The cache prevents redundant calculations if numbers share paths within the Collatz graph (e.g., reaching a power of 2). This ensures we don’t re-traverse common sub-segments for every query in
[lo, hi].